The Reno Game

Reno Case Files

Real deals. Real numbers. Real complications. When conventional financing sees a problem — renovation financing sees the plan.

ByDustin Swigart·Renovation Lending Specialist·25 Years in Renovation Lending
Last Updated:
Case File #001 — Opelika, Alabama: C5 condition historic home financed to $450,000 after-renovation value
Case File #001Location: Opelika, AlabamaProperty: 1907 Historic HomeLoan Type: FHA 203(k) StandardBorrower information and property address withheld for privacy.
The situation

A homeowner was trying to purchase a 1907 historic home in Opelika, Alabama. She started with a traditional bank and was told the property could potentially go conventional.

Then the appraisal came back.

Appraisal findings
Condition: C5
  • Significant deferred maintenance
  • Water damage
  • Possible structural concerns
  • Nonfunctional plumbing fixtures
  • Multiple inspections and repairs needed before the home could be considered livable and structurally sound
  • Approximately $33,000 in identified repairs
  • Potential $30,000 roof replacement pending inspection

This wasn't a conventional-loan house.

How she found me

That's when she found me — through ChatGPT. When the conventional path closed, she asked AI where to turn for a house in this condition. It sent her here.

The strategy

We stopped trying to make the house fit the wrong financing and started looking at what the property could become. We built the renovation plan around the property.

Renovation budget
Construction costs$101,760
Contingency + allowable fees~$13,606
Total renovation side~$115,366
The result

We ordered the renovation appraisal based on the home after completion of the proposed improvements. The appraiser evaluated the property subject to completion of the renovation scope.

Condition
C5C3
Effective Age
70 years10 years
Appraised Value
Distressed$450,000
After-Renovation Value
$450,000

Same house. Same buyer. Different strategy.

That's what renovation financing is really about.

Don't just look at what a property is. Learn how to finance what it can become.

Case File #002 — Willoughby, Ohio: 930 sq ft ranch expanded to 1,993 sq ft 4-bedroom home via HomeStyle renovation loan, $375,000 ARV
Case File #002Location: Willoughby, OhioProperty: 1955 Ranch — Second Floor AdditionLoan Type: HomeStyle Renovation LoanBorrower information and property address withheld for privacy.
The situation

These homeowners shopped and shopped, trying to find something that gave them what they needed. But there was a problem.

They already loved where they lived.

What they had
  • 11 years in the neighborhood
  • ~930 sq. ft. one-story ranch built 1955
  • Deep roots — the neighborhood was the right answer
  • A house that no longer fit the life they were building
The question that changed everything

Instead of paying more for someone else's version of the right house, they asked a different question: What if we just create the house we want?

The strategy

We structured a HomeStyle Renovation Loan to take their roughly 930 sq. ft. one-story ranch and add an entire 1,064 sq. ft. second floor — transforming it into an approximately 1,993 sq. ft., 4-bedroom home.

Scope of work
Complete 2nd floor addition
New roof
New siding & exterior trim
HVAC modifications
Interior reconfiguration
New electrical
Plumbing modifications
New kitchen
New flooring throughout
Asbestos related work

Engineering analysis confirmed the existing foundation is adequate for the proposed second floor addition.

The result
Square Footage
~930 sq. ft.~1,993 sq. ft.
Bedrooms
Ranch layout4 bed / 2 bath
Stories
1 story2 stories
After-Renovation Value
$375,000

No moving truck. No giving up the neighborhood. No settling.

That's the part of renovation financing people sometimes miss.

It isn't always about buying an ugly house and fixing it. Sometimes it's about realizing you may already own the location of your next home.

More case files coming

Every deal has a story. The Reno Case Files are being built out with real renovation financing scenarios — the kind of deal-level detail you won't find in a generic guide.

Have a deal that needs a different strategy? Talk to Dustin →

Have a Property in Mind?

Found a property that needs work? Send me the property address, purchase price and what you're considering renovating.

Send Me a Reno Scenario